| Platinum | Sandfiddler Cafe |
| Gold | Handsome Biscuit |
| Silver | Karla's Beach House Restaurant |
| Bronze | Bel Aire Pancake House |
| Top Pick | Baker's Crust Artisan Kitchen |
| Top Pick | D'Egg West |
| Top Pick | Harbor Inn |
| Top Pick | Little Dog Diner |
| Top Pick | Terrie's Breakfast and Lunch |
| Top Pick | The Norfolk Grille |