| Platinum | Franco's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Fellini's |
| Silver | Regino's Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Franco's By The Bay |
| Top Pick | Amale Tre Focacceria |
| Top Pick | District Apizza |
| Top Pick | Granby Street Pizza |
| Top Pick | Razzo |
| Top Pick | Sal's Famous Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ynot Italian |