| Platinum | Cogan's Pizza |
| Gold | Del Vecchios Pizza |
| Silver | Regino's Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Sharks Sports Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Azalea Inn |
| Top Pick | Fellini's |
| Top Pick | Granby Street Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lomo Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mona Lisa Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | The Bakehouse at Chelsea |